[pubcookie-dev] pubcookie in country code TLDs

Lawrence Greenfield leg+ at andrew.cmu.edu
Wed Jan 15 11:51:28 PST 2003


   Date: Wed, 15 Jan 2003 11:30:47 -0600 (CST)
   From: "RL 'Bob' Morgan" <rlmorgan at washington.edu>
[...]
   Oy, horrible is right.  But I'm sure someone said, hey, "co.uk." has the
   same sort of real-world meaning as ".com.", that is entities under it have
   to be assumed to be mutually non-trusting, so setting a cookie with a
   scope such that it could be passed between them is bad, so let's make the
   browser not do that.  Of course if it really were bad presumably security
   advisories would have been issued for those browsers that permit it.  And
   of course there are so many ways of passing info between domains if you
   want to (embedded images etc) that this restriction is rather silly.  But
   if it's reality with IE then it is.

Their heart was in the right place.

   I guess the good thing is that any solution we come up with to do
   cross-DNS-domain operation will solve this problem too.

Steve was looking at that some time ago; I thought this had become a
higher priority for UW. Has anything happened with this?

Larry



More information about the pubcookie-dev mailing list